Thursday, January 17, 2013

introducing everyday justice


This is where I want to convince you to think about the places you shop.  This is where I want to persuade you that there is a reason to pay a bit more for that icon that says “fair trade” on your bag of beans.  This is where I want to let you know that your oil consumption is probably just as great because of the plastic products you purchase as it is because of the gas you put in your car, and that that’s a problem.  This is where I want to convince you to join a CSA and to support local growers.

And I don’t quite know how you’ll respond.  When I have written in the past about some of my resolutions to try to move towards a more earth-friendly menu, or to buyslavery-free, I’ve written with the assumption that anyone reading here would understand the reasons behind those goals.

But maybe the ideas are new to you, and overwhelming.  (If they are, we should begin with this disclaimer: Don’t panic.)

Or maybe you’ve heard this before and thought, “I’m a free-market capitalist.  The market will work these things out,” or, “This is just too complex – how can we ever know what is right?” or “These things may be important, but they are not as important as the gospel.”

Here is where I want to say that this is about the gospel;  and not just the “social gospel,” because that's not really a distinction that Jesus made.

Here is where I want to say that absolutely, this is too complex, but that’s not a reason to stop trying to understand what is right.

Here is where I want to say that free-market capitalism in America is a little bit broken (and refer you to Marilynne Robinson’s fine essay “Austerity as Idealogy” for more on that).

Here is where I want to tell you that if you cried in Les Miserables, let your heart be stirred by the fact that slavery, prostitution, corrupt governments, and broken systems are running nearly unchecked in our world today too.  Part of our kingdom work is to fight them in whatever ways we can, to be on that barricade in the final scene, beating our swords into ploughshares.

But here is also where I want to confess to you that I act against my own convictions all the time.  That I bought a jacket on sale at Target this weekend that was almost certainly made by people (possibly children) who, at the very least, aren’t able to earn a living wage making it, and who more likely are caught in a corrupt system leading to inescapable debt that makes their factory work the equivalent of slave labor.  I want to confess that I drive through fast food places.  That I buy avocados and bananas shipped in from far away.

I believe that these things do matter, and to say that they don’t, or that they’re not our concern, or that they’re too complicated is to allow a syncretistic “American” version of Christianity to rule our hearts, where “free market”= Christian,  and materialism and thoughtless consumerism are “lesser” sins. 

We are blinded by our own prosperity, and even when our vision clears for a moment, we quickly forget what we’ve seen.

“Those factories that run on the labor of children, filling our world with some many attractive products that are really much cheaper than they ought to be – have they gone away? No, but our attention has wandered, and that is the next best thing from the point of view of our spiritual comfort.  From the point of view of our material comfort, it is certainly the best thing.” (Marilynne Robinson, in  “Austerity and Ideology”)

My attention is wandering all the time, so what I really wanted to say here is that this year I’m taking steps to abide in my resolutions toward seeking justice in my daily choices.  This year I’m going to abide in Julie Clawson’s beginner’s guide to Everyday Justice, and as my book group here in Upland works through the chapters on coffee, chocolate, cars, food, clothes, waste, and debt, I’m going to share about them in this space too.  I’ll summarize Clawson's ideas, share some excerpts from the book, and list practical steps that we can take towards more just decision-making.  Because

“If you get rid of unfair practices,
Quit blaming victims,
Quit gossiping about other people’s sins,

If you are generous with the hungry
And start giving yourselves to the down and out,

Your lives will begin to glow in the darkness,
Your shadowed lives will be bathed in sunlight.”
(from Isaiah 58, The Message)

I’ll need your help – argue with me, help me find updated information (the book was published in 2009), and share what you’ve learned in each of the areas. Heck, buy the book and read it along with us! 

I’m prone to wander, and prone to get rant-y, but I want my life to glow in the darkness, and this year, this is where I’ll begin.

8 comments:

Melissa said...

OH MAN! This is my first visit here but I will be back! Our book lists even look the same. I've started a ministry at my church called "Pursuit Justice" and this week we are looking at fair trade and engaging with global issues from where we are! AND we are watching LIVE 58 (based on the verse you quoted). AND I am off to buy the book you suggested! Looks perfect!

Amy Lepine Peterson said...

Welcome, Melissa! I do hope you will stick around and share your input. I'd love to learn from you as you learn at church.

Christie Purifoy said...

Looking forward to these discussions. Also, I'll be checking out that Robinson essay.
And three cheers for the CSA. I don't know what I'd do without mine.

Julie Dufford said...

YES! And, it doesn't always require "paying more". The baby wipes I bought at the Dollar Tree are "made in USA". It's also great to learn what justice charities different corporations support. I think I'll be exploring that too, in the coming months. Thanks Amy, for your thoughtful heartfelt comments!

mollie said...

Let me first say that I totally agree that we should be mindful of the implications of our purchases, that there are major flaws in capitalism and that there are serious labor abuses that need to be addressed worldwide. That said, I'm still going to share this brief defense of sweatshops, with which I happen to agree: http://aidwatchers.com/2010/08/help-the-worlds-poor-buy-some-new-clothes/
If you are interested, there's a more thorough analysis here: http://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2008/Powellsweatshops.html

Amy Lepine Peterson said...

That's a helpful perspective to add to the discussion.

When I worked in phnom penh, I knew a number of khmers who worked in American garment factories. They were certainly thankful for the work, which was a step up from their previous subsistence farming. But- one family I knew- had a little debt from medical bills. The wages from their factory work was literally never going to be enough to allow them to eat and pay off their debt, both.

The study compares sweatshop wages to other in-country wages and says it's good. It says Americans get freaked out because it just seems so low compared to *our* wages. But I'm not interested in comparing wages to ours or to other in-cointry wages. I'm interested in comparing them to the cost of living. There are factories that do pay a living wage, and I'm all in favor of them.when a researcher says that people willingly take sweatshop jobs because they are the best available, I want to know why there isn't a better option. And when's researcher says the company is paying what it can afford to pay and still make a profit, I want to know exactly what thechristmas bonuses we for the CEO and CFO.

But this goes back to the "too complicated" part- so there are good factories and bad factories, and no way for us to know which one made our clothes . At this point in my life, instead of assuming that the people who made the clothes were happy to have a job, I want to at least try to find out a little more. If its possible to use my consumer vote to say that I believe factories should be safe places (you read about the fire in a Bangladesh factory were a hundred people died a couple months ago?) that pay a living wage and don't use slave labor, then I want to find out how to do that.

PS I typed this on mobile and it's rife with spelling mistakes. S I'm having a hard time taking mysElf seriously!

Amy Lepine Peterson said...

To be clear, I do agree with you that a valid defense of (some) "sweatshops" can be made.

I just don't want to use that as an excuse to stop thinking about how I can help reform the abuse that exists within the systems.

Also: I think the repercussions for earth's resources really need to be considered in our clothing purchases - there's more about that in my old review of the book "Overdressed".

mollie said...

I agree - it's no excuse to stop thinking about how to make things better. And it certainly says nothing in regard to wasting the earth's resources, which I think is critical. I look forward to the discussion and reading your thoughts on the book!! Perhaps I'll read it too...